Schools do not always act transparently and openly in relation to the practices they use to respond to students with disabilities.
If you are a school mentioned on this page and believe the information you see is factually incorrect, please contact us. Similarly, if you are a school mentioned on this website and the information we have posted was correct, but has been superseded by some formal policy, personnel or procedural change, please contact us and provide that information in order that we are able to consider publishing any change to procedures/approach. As at January 2025, no school mentioned has corrected the information posted about it.
For more details on violent practices against students in individual schools and responses by DoE, see the attached submission to the Federal Senate Inquiry into the abuse of people with disabilities. DoE was provided with an opportunity to counter all or any allegations in this report, and in its response, did not do so.
Senate Inquiry into Abuse of People with Disabilities Submission.
For more details on the failure of individual schools to educate children with disabilities and their inability to write Individual Education Plans, see the attached submission to the Federal Senate inquiry into educational attainment for students with disabilities. Submission Senate Inquiry Educational Attainment
While these reports are 2015/2016, little has changed since then.
It should be noted that the term “restrictive practices” is referring to practices that are nearly always unnecessary, as they are being carried out in the absence of evidence-based behavioural strategies. In these situations, such practices should be seen as violence, abuse and neglect.
The 2024 report from Royal Commission into Violence Abuse Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disabilities Volume 7 provides more information about schools across Australia in the context of students with disabilities. https://disability.royalcommission.gov.au/publications/final-report
While parents may wish to use this as a guide to what may or may not be a suitable school for their child with a disability, parents without children with a disability may also wish to reflect on the general culture of a school environment where children with disabilities are not welcome and/or are mistreated.
Last Updated January 2025
ALFREDTON PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Restraint and seclusion reported as being used against child with Autism Spectrum Disorder.
Restraint documented. Seclusion observed.
BALLARAT CRISTIAN COLLEGE
A number of students with disabilities banned from school activities due to “behaviours”.
A number of students with disabilities have left the college.
Behaviour contracts used.
BALNARRING PRIMARY SCHOOL
This school has had two discrimination complaints lodged against it. In one case, despite being provided parent and medical evidence of a child’s serious mental health deterioration due to their treatment at the school, the school continued the same treatment, being refusal to allow the student full-time enrolment. The student was forced to leave the school on medical advice.
This also occurred with another child in 2016, with the same 1-2 hour restriction until they left. Another child was required to leave the school due to bullying, unaddressed by the school.
Most recently, staff for years managed to miss the fact that a boy had a learning disorder until it was too late. When asked to urgently put in intensive evidence based remedial programs, they put in place Toe by Toe for a few minutes per day. Their responses to behaviours of concern are behaviour contracts, isolation and punishment. Sandra O’Meara organised a suspension notice which had no end date to be sent to a child’s parents. Ms O’Meara refused to provide an end date and the child’s advocate had to go to the region, by which time Ms O’Meara had been able to force the boy to stay at home for weeks. Original document still held.
Note marking of maths questions for child with learning disorders. 12×5=50. 9 divide by 3= 6. This is one of a few with similar errors. Balnarring Maths
This school uses Tresspass Orders against parents complaining about the treatment of students with disabilities.
BARINGA SPECIAL SCHOOL
Behaviour Responses
Uses martial arts experts to train staff in behaviour interventions (see website of James Sumarac http://www.jamessumarac.com/challenging-behaviour-solutions.php)
BENDIGO SPECIAL DEVELOPMENTAL SCHOOL Restrictive Practices
Restrictive Practices
Multiple internal and external seclusion areas in use for many years. Photographs supplied.
Inhumane and degrading seclusion areas used in recent past (see Senate Committee Report “Violence, abuse and neglect against people with disability in institutional and residential settings” November 2015 p104 Senate Report Abuse of People with Disabilities)
Multiple reports and documented evidence of cages in classes used.
Staff trained by martial arts expert James Sumarac.
Staff trained in the use of pressure points.
Staff claim they place students with epilepsy in pens/cages post seizure for their safety.
Structure below erected at Bendigo SDS “in accordance with the student’s Behaviour Management Plan” in “consultation with the Department’s OHS Representatives”. (quote taken from investigation into Bendigo Special Developmental School)
The pen Bendigo SDS staff put students, they claim for “self-regulation”.
Investigation into Bendigo Special Developmental school
New Principal since 2016. While failing to criticise what had occurred at the school, Minister James Merlino admitted that the cages had been taken out of classrooms. Some of the same staff accused of (and witnessed using) violence against students with disabilities remain. Current Principal Kirsty McAinsh defended the school’s past practices in October 2023 via the Bendigo Advertiser.
BILLANOOK COLLEGE
Disability discrimination complaint 2023. College does not hold termly SSGs, does not collaborate with parents in relation to Individual Education Plans. Allegedly had an IEP in place but did not show it to the parents for eight months. Student had to leave on advice from allied health practitioners due to mental health deterioration.
BONA VISTA PRIMARY SCHOOL
This school is reported to be extremely welcoming of students with disabilities and embraces difference. It is flexible with its learning style. It is reported to be very accepting of the different idiosyncrasies that students with cognitive disabilities may have. It provides excellent recovery opportunities for students who have been forced out of Drouin and Drouin South Primary Schools. 2023
BULLEEN HEIGHTS SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Physical restraint reported against children with Autism Spectrum Disorder. Video footage.
Use of locked court yard for children with Autism Spectrum Disorder – numerous reports. Photographed.
Promotion of medication to parents reported.
Martial Arts expert has trained staff in restraint.
Behaviour Responses
Endorse having Behaviour Plans in staff members “heads”, written on whiteboards and placed on walls – no document available to parents.
CAMPBELLS CREEK PRIMARY SCHOOL
Three discrimination complaints lodged in 2023.
Segregation of students with disabilities.
Rather than behavioural support, school uses restricted attendance to deal with behaviours of concern, to the point that one student has missed out on most of his six years primary school education.
Staff get involved in medication decisions, urging increases rather than paying for supports.
Student restrained by staff in 2023. Staff deny despite documented bruising by medical professional.
Principal needed to be threatened with an intervention order to stop contacting parent.
WorkCover claims by staff, numerous experienced staff have left.
Principal Rosemary Critchley – previously worked at Bendigo SDS during period of regular false imprisonment of children, cages in classrooms, multiple allegations of physical assault of children by staff.
CASTLEMAINE SECONDARY COLLEGE
This school is run with an iron fist by Principal Justin Hird in relation to students with disabilities. Regardless of the lack of expert behaviour support brought into the school, suspensions are used prolifically. It is unclear whether the school leadership team are completely unaware of the research on suspensions, indicating a lack of professional development in the last 10 years, or are deliberately attempting to incite students with disabilities through suspensions.
Like many other schools, reports to Child Protection are used in response to parents who complain.
CRANBOURNE EAST SECONDARY COLLEGE
Discrimination complaint against the school 2018. Staff reinforce behaviours of concern by teaching students that if they demonstrate behaviours they can go home. Refusal to allow one child more than two hours a day of attendance. Failure to teach functional communication. Failure to educate-little respect for capacity of students who are non-verbal. Legal Division heavily involved in directing the education of students with disabilities who make complaints.
CROYDON SPECIAL DEVELOPMENTAL SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Assault and false imprisonment of children leaving injuries. 2021/2022. Practices fully supported by Department of Education.
DANDENONG VALLEY SPECIAL SCHOOL
Behaviour Responses
Have used martial arts expert to train staff in behaviour interventions (James Sumarac )
DROUIN PRIMARY SCHOOL
Two discrimination complaints lodged against the school. School handles behaviours of concern by restricting attendance, suspensions and expulsion. Principal found not to have followed proper expulsion procedure. The school is considered a mental health risk for students with cognitive disabilities e.g. Autism, ADHD, ODD etc. Student subjected to exclusion from excursions, exclusion from classrooms. Principal-Brad Whellar.
DROUIN SOUTH PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Two discrimination complaints lodged against the school. Bullying against students with disabilities long-standing and neglected. Principal refuses to provide incident reports on staff violence and student to student violence to parents. Multiple suspensions used against students with behaviours of concern, no behaviour plan in place, suspension procedures not followed. Student reports of violence against students by principal, Michael Smith, school refused to respond. Students with behaviours of concern are restricted from school attendance (eg to 2 hours per day) rather than a behaviour supports being put in place. Incident reports also being held back by the FOI Unit. Parent has reported bullying by principal. Region refuses to respond to parents in relation to complaint.
School receiving disability funds on the basis of false reports from Department of Education student support services officers who undertook assessments without consent and failed to provide assessments to parents.
Failure to hold Student Support Group meetings, failure to provide suspension notices. 2019
EASTERN RANGES (Wantirna Heights School) Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Child with Autism Spectrum Disorder repeatedly placed in bathroom in response to challenging behaviours. Sharp surfaces, door sometimes shut, no register, no parental consent.
Martial Arts expert has trained staff in restraint.
“Timeout” Room door locked, windows covered. Photograph supplied.
Since moving to Ferntree Gully, no personal observations of seclusion room, however seclusion continues in to 2018, using ‘courtyards’.
Reports and photographs of child injured on numerous occasions at new school, no incident reports.
Child secluded in outdoor pen in winter in response to vomiting. 2018
Respond to behaviours with punishment. Two discrimination complaints against it.
Behaviour Responses
Behaviour Plans in staff members “heads” – no document available to parents.
Individual Learning Plans
Staff claim that school reports are Individual Learning Plans
Injuries
Parent reports multiple injuries to child over a two year period, documented by photographs, no incident reports provided, psychological deterioration in child, medical assistance needed, left school. Upon change of school all psychological symptoms gone, injuries ceased.
Practices fully supported by Department of Education.
EPPALOCK PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Numerous students with disabilities withdrawn from this school.
Physical Restraint reported.
Bullying including sexualised bullying.
Unable to effectively work with behaviours of concern.
Numerous parents report psychological deterioration in their children prior to withdrawal.
“Unwritten” behaviour plans used.
Vast improvements reported as at 2018.
ESSEX HEIGHTS PRIMARY SCHOOL
Staff
Aides procured for a child with moderate-severe Autism Spectrum Disorder and severe behaviours of concern included the school’s maintenance man, and a local school crossing supervisor.
FITZROY PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices
Physical restraint used in preference to professional behaviour support. Prohibited physical restraints used. Restraints not reported to parents. Restraint policy is not complied with. Individual education plans withheld from student with disabilities. Student Support Group guidelines not followed.
Victimisation of parents. Heavy use of suspensions. Practices fully supported by Department of Education.
Discrimination complaint settled 2022.
FRANKSTON SDS
Students have left the school, showing signs of significant trauma.
GOLDEN SQUARE PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Parent/child reports child with autism taped to chair.
Physical restraint used on more than one child. Photograph of injury supplied.
School merged with Maple Street Primary School.
HAMPTON PARK SECONDARY COLLEGE
Numerous discrimination complaints against the school. Refusal to enrol, refusal to provide reasonable adjustments. Staff don’t understand what evidence-based literacy programs are. Discrimination caused suicidal ideation in student. When student expressed suicidal tendencies, parents were not advised until the next day. Principal Wayne Haworth breached agreement made at the Australian Human Rights Commission. Practices fully supported by Department of Education.
IVANHOE EAST PRIMARY SCHOOL
Three discrimination complaints lodged 2015-2017. Involved deliberate placement of a student with physical disabilities up stairs, requiring her to use dangerous external emergency stairway on side of building. Reports to Principal of serious mental health problems due to trauma of enrolment – no appropriate action taken. Serious long standing serious and physical bullying issues of a student with a disability, unaddressed by the school. Student with disabilities assaulted, photographs taken of injuries, by bullies. Absence of any compassion shown. Legal Division heavily involved in complaints by the parents of students with disabilities. Practices fully supported by Department of Education.
Principal Justine Mackay.
JACKSON SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive Practices
Case study: Child attending from 2005-2016. Frequent physical restraint – documentation of individual incidents. No formal Student Support Group meetings, no formal Individual Education Plan for the enrolment period. Multiple suspensions. No Formal Behaviour Plan, no intensive behaviour support for the enrolment. As soon as the student left the school, behaviours of concern ceased, except for trauma related behaviours due to treatment. Discrimination complaint made 2018, frequent physical restraint isolation and exclusion. No intensive communication/language support. 2018 SBS documentary reveals attitudes towards students who cannot communicate “not a priority”. Parent witnessed Principal Joan O’Connor Cox opening door to seclusion room where student was lying on the ground, no air-conditioning, no supports. Practices fully supported by Department of Education.
KENNINGTON PRIMARY SCHOOL
School presents a risk to children as disclosures of abuse by teachers are rejected in favour of staff.
A deaf student was assaulted by one specific teacher in the Deaf Facility during the period of a year, verbally abused and mocked.
Principal Travis Eddy found the allegations unsubstantiated, despite an independent witness hearing the same teacher yell at the student in question. Student was expected to work one-on-one with the teacher who she accused of assault, after she disclosed the assaults to the Principal.
Mr Eddy, in saying the assault allegations were unsubstantiated, seemed to excuse the teacher’s actions by saying “emotional expression; facial expressions and body language are essential for conveying emotions, attitudes and feelings.”
Student had to leave the school for her own safety given she had disclosed directly to the principal what had occurred, and the teacher’s version was preferred.
Discrimination complaint lodged 2024.
KILBERRY VALLEY PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
This school has changed its approach to students of disabilities since a Vice Principal left. Once a flagship for DET Inclusion, there has been evidence of the school attempting not to enrol students with disabilities, and complaints of discrimination have been and are being made against the school in 2019. Complaints involve a presumption of complete lack of capacity, inability to write meaningful Individual Education Plans, failure to teach communication for students who are non-verbal, and in one case, a persuasive argument as to why a student, for the sixth year in a row, should have goal of making a mark on a piece of paper. Phsycial restraint used as ‘de-escalation’ strategies.
LATROBE SDS Warning
Multiple complaints including litigation. Serious injury, bullying, grooming, staff recorded suggesting students should be put in a cage and fight each other. “Independent” investigation 2022. Like other investigations, report sent back to the DET with no public accountability. As a result, many parents not participating in investigation. Bullying of honest staff, staff on WorkCover, many students removed by parents. Legal action for negligence settled 2023. Sexual assaults of students by other students. Practices fully supported by Department of Education.Barbara Walsh Principal at the time students were sexually assaulting other students on numerous occasions, known to staff. Nicole Herbert Principal 2024, responded in a manner to an allegation aof sexual assault of a student in a manner which constituted neglect, but continues to be principal at school.
LOCH PRIMARY SCHOOL
Parents of children with learning disabilities have found this school very welcoming and open to using evidence-based and best practice approaches in relation to the learning of literacy and numeracy.
MAHOGANY RISE STUDENT DEVOPMENT CENTRE Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Physical restraint.
The form below was distributed to parents in June 2016. Due to outcry, it was withdrawn, however schools do not actually require parental permission to restrain under the Department of Education’s oft quoted Regulation 15 (now Reg 25) of the Education and Training Reform Act.
Mahogany Rise restraint permission form
MANOR LAKES SECONDARY COLLEGE Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Restraint used against student with Autism. Documented.
Staff have been trained by martial arts expert.
Student reports being hit in throat by maintenance man/ju jitsu trainer.
MANSFIELD AUTISTIC STATEWIDE SERVICES Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive Practices
Mansfield has a school which it operates out of its main headquarters. Charging thousands of dollars, and despite one of their mottos being “supporting people to achieve dignity without restraint”, restraining and secluding children with behaviours of concern is exactly what they do. They subject children with behaviours of concern to restrictive practices without bringing in behavioural experts to undertake Functional Behaviour Assessments, and therefore their internal behaviour plans fail and children/young people are instead subjected to violence from staff. Discrimination complaint made against them.
MAPLE STREET PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Physical restraint repeatedly used against student with Autism Spectrum Disorder (see Bendigo Advertiser 9 April 2013). Documented.
Staff trained in restraint. School Psychologist endorsed.
MARNEBEK SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Mechanical and physical restraint, and seclusion used against students. Multiple reports. Documented.
Students shut in high fenced court yards and locked in small time out room.
Records show students in ‘time out’ for significant periods of time.
An FOI request for the “Timeout register” in 2020 revealed that against DET procedure, Marnebek was not recording most of the occasions that it was falsely imprisoning children.
Student Support Group meetings do not comply with DET guidelines.
Written complaints about restraint not responded to by Principal. Correspondence sighted.
The “Senior Clinician and Challenging Behaviour Analyst” from 2010 to 2016 was a social worker.
Students leaving the school due to grievances have shown immediate and significant improvements in academic, social and behaviour skill areas. See (‘Leaving Marnebek’ document)
Behaviour Plans were generally developed by teachers and the “Challenging Behaviour Analyst”.
At least 4 legal cases have been lodged against Marnebek, one unsuccessful (VCAT), one successful and two settled by DET.
Kathy Weston has been AP for the years abuse has taken place.
Staff
Despite the complexity of the student population, teachers do not need to be special education trained and aides are not required to have any qualification. One aide working with children with severe Autism Spectrum Disorder, for example, previously worked at Kmart directly before working at Marnebek. This staff member was recorded swearing at a child.
The Allied Health Clinical Services Team Leader was found on social media to describe a male with Asperger’s as a “dead set weirdo” and “not the full picnic” due to the fact that he wasn’t following social rules in public.
Despite many of the above problems going back to 2012, Marnebek has not changed, see article below as at 2024.
MELTON SECONDARY COLLEGE
Few supports for students with disabilities, no formal Student Support Group meetings, no best practice Individual Education Plans. Widespread bullying of a physical nature which presents a significant danger to students with disabilities. Bullying not addressed by staff.
MONASH SPECIAL DEVELOPMENTAL SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Photographic evidence of children strapped into chairs and strollers in order to address children running around. Some chairs nailed to boards to further restrict children. Children tied to toilets.
In August 2014, ANZUK, an educational recruitment agency, advertised for aides with martial arts training to work with children with disabilities in schools in a number of suburbs, including Wheelers Hill. Monash SDS denied they have aides trained in martial arts but could not nominate an alternative school in Wheelers Hill that the advertisement may have been referring to. School admits to restrictive practices, using harnesses to control children on a daily basis. Children also tied to toilets.
General
The former Principal Helen McCoy had ties to Anne Hamilton-Burne from the cult, ‘the Family’. See http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/battle-for-control-as-cult-leader-deteriorates-20130721-2qcoc.html
Consultants providing professional development to the school have included Conflict Management International, who have a background in police, military and martial arts.
Student Support Group meetings can be held without parents, even if the parent requests the meeting.
Subsequent to parents complaining about inappropriate practices, the Principal created a policy preventing parents from taking their children to the classrooms during school hours. Parents who complained report victimisation and deteriorating relationships with all staff.
Students pulled out due to grievances have shown an immediate improvement in skill areas.
Serious incidents not always documented.
In 2016, a student was left on a bus as the bus company did not check the bus, and the Monash class teacher did not follow up the student’s unexplained absence. In 2018, Principal on leave, unsure of return. In December 2020, Ms McCoy’s wildlife organisation was found to have inappropriately received assets in order that The Family could avoid payouts to victims of assault. Complaint to Department of Education and Training in relation to Ms McCoy was not upheld. DET supported Ms McCoy until she left, despite her involvement in a cult sexually abusing children.
Practices fully defended by Department of Education.
MT ERIN SECONDARY COLLEGE
Several discrimination complaints against Mt Erin lodged between 2009 and 2014. Settled by Department of Education and Training. Complaints continued to be made about how the school treat students with disabilities. One individual education plan sighted 2018, there were derogatory comments about the student included in the plan.
OLYMPIC VILLAGE PRIMARY SCHOOL (formerly Charles Latrobe Primary School
Parents had to withdraw their child with autism in late 2016 when instead of agreeing to put in place the recommendations in a Functional Behaviour Assessment to address self injurious behaviour, the Principal refused and suggested instead “the use of protective head wear to minimise the impact any head banging may have upon” development.
PENINSULA SPECIAL SCHOOL Restrictive practices
Students with behaviours of concern subjected to suspensions and restricted attendance rather than evidence based behavioural approaches. Functional communication not taught. Little effort put into the education of students with intellectual disability. One student left the school after 4 1/2 years having virtually no academic skills despite no intellectual disability. Correspondence from parents to Peter Koop Principal often ignored. Bullying repeatedly reported. Discrimination complaints lodged in 2018, 2021, 2022 and 2024. Physical attacks on students by other students. These have involved weapons. At least one student diagnosed with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder due to treatment by other students and the Principal.
As of the end of 2022, Peter Koop on leave.
2023 sexual assault student to student, twice in one day – despite victim allegedly having one-to-one supervision. Mother not called when sexual assault occurred. Principal Trevor Hodsdon refuses to respond to correspondence for weeks/months on end in relation to these matters. School has allowed victim and perpetrator to be in contact since the assaults, Despite request from family that they are can have no contact.. Student reported inappropriate conduct by an aide indicating that aide should not be in contact with children. School failed to investigate. School failed to keep perpetrator away from victim and allowed them to have close contact mid 2024.No support provided to victim to assist him to cope with the sexual assault. No support provided to family.
Student support group guidelines not followed.
Individual Education Plans guidelines not followed.
Child Safety Standards not adhered to.
School constitutes a danger to children due to the above.
RINGWOOD NORTH PRIMARY SCHOOL Positive Report
After a child with Autism had attended three primary schools, suffering bullying to the point of suicidal ideation, suspension and expulsion due to behaviours of concern, exclusion, and isolation he was enrolled at Ringwood North Primary School.
No suspensions, no exclusion, involvement in excursions, positive interactions, leading to almost complete mitigation of behaviours of concern. Child thriving.
RIPPLEBROOK PRIMARY SCHOOL
Since a new principal in late 2015, the school has deteriorated in relation to its handling of students with disabilities, which it does with suspension rather than any evidence based behaviour approaches. Discrimination complaint lodged against the school in 2017. Settled. Second discrimination complaint, 2022.
SOMERS PRIMARY SCHOOL
This school has a discrimination complaint against it as at 2021. The Principal Hugh Greer undertakes Functional Behaviour Assessments for children with behaviours of concern without consent. When asked what his qualifications were to do such an assessment, he refused to respond, with the backing of the Region, on approximately 4/5 occasions. Legal Division heavily involved in the education of students with disabilities who make complaints. Constant requests for information are obstructed. Child at risk of death due to staff refusing to follow anaphylaxis plan. Does not welcome parent input into Individual Education Plans and Behaviour Plans. No knowledge of what SMART goals are. Principal given medical certificate on multiple occasions to tell him to stop contacting a female parent and refused. Parent has medical report stating these interactions caused psychological damage. Falsifies minutes disparaging parents and then refuses to correct. Practices fully supported by Department of Education.
SOUTHERN AUTISTIC SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported – multiple
Behaviour Responses –
Has endorsed the use of martial arts experts in behaviour interventions (James Sumarac)
See photograph provided of high fenced empty asphalt area where children are placed.
As recently as 2018, child has reported being tied up with rope and subjected to prone restraint. Medical evidence supports claim both physically and mentally. One parent has witnessed tent in cupboard for child with behaviours of concern.
More than one parent has reported child coming home with bruises, with no explanation from staff when approached. Multiple accounts of negligence and physical violence reported by parents and their own staff. One child kept in an external tent.
Individual Education Plans viewed for a number of children suggest little attempt to educate students-no strategies, no measurable outcomes. Functional communication not taught, communication devices not used. Three discrimination complaints lodged against school in 2018. Some school council members openly support restrictive practices against children.
More than one student witnessed others being tied up. Therapy involvement minimal.
One staff member has reported sanctioned practice by teacher of student being allowed to masturbate in the classroom under a sheet with a sex toy.
Witnesses from neighbouring school observed children naked in playground.
No evidence based programs – when parents ask for such they have been refused. Sends students to sheltered workshops. No following of Victorian Curriculum – school claims activities such as picking up rubbish, weeding, cleaning and riding around in a bus are part of the curriculum.
Lowest expectations of its students, justifying lack of academic teaching due to lack of capacity. Multiple discrimination complaints. Last one settled 2023. Victorian Department of Education fully support school approach to treatment of students with disabilities, therefore no change is expected at this school.
ST JOSEPHS SCHOOL WONTHAGGI
This school has been the subject of a number of nonlegal and legal complaints in relation to its treatment of students with disabilities. It uses the discredited Fountas & Pinnell literacy methodology. One parent has complained about the physical restraint of her child at the school. Parent feedback is unwelcome and lack of acceptable student progress is not enough for a change in educational approach. Two discrimination complaints against the school in 2018, one more in 2020 and claim of false and misleading representations. Response to complaints – aggressive, hostile, threatening.
In 2021, Acting Principal Joanne Coldabella refused a request, in non-compliance with privacy legislation, to provide personal information in a student’s file. January 2022, request still not complied with. Refuses to follow guidelines from the Catholic Education Commission of Victoria.
2023 finally were forced to provide their notes, indicating awareness of student feeling suicidal but continued to refuse to provide the reasonable adjustments requested by parents. Ms Coldabella rewarded by promotion to Principal.
SUNSHINE SDS
Another special school which is so neglectful and abusive it has attracted an investigation as of 2022, which as per DoE standard investigations found no abuse of students to disabilities. Parents had to drug their children just to attend. Student to student assaults resulting in hospitalisations. Over 50 staff left by end of 2022. Little attempt at genuine teaching as per Individual Education Plans. Children falsely imprisoned in external areas. At least one student allowed to roam around school grounds unsupervised. Neighbours complained of children naked in the school ground open to the public eye. One child educated in the bus shed. Principal Nicole Edwardes.
New Principal 2023. School allowed student to be picked up and taken away by a stranger in 2023. Individual Education Plans indicate continued babysitting despite new Principal.
Examples of goals from 2023/2024.
“xxx will describe the question the data display is displaying.”
“xxx will use pictures to record observations about the weather.” This young man was in his second last year of school and is capable of typing words.
There is no right to communicate at the school, and no expectation that a student will be able to functionally communicate by the time they leave school, despite their abilities to do so. No formal PECS program is used, no formal communication plan of any type is used.
Department of Education fully supports the approach of the school. Discrimination complaint by seven parents current at 2025.
SYDENHAM HILLSIDE PRIMARY SCHOOL
Individual Education Plan
Measurable outcomes in IEP for child with Autism included the following:
“Home Work” “Class Work” “Discussions”
Strategy for addressing 3+ year literacy delay includes for spelling:
“ ’Johnny’ will be given three words to learn at home.”
IEP sighted. Parent left school after attempting to negotiate IEP for 7 months.
Official DET response is that there is no minimum requirement for any type of quality for an Individual Education Plan. Confirmed by Victorian Auditor General.
TRAFALGAR PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices
School staff started restraining child when he was 5 years old in Prep. Repeated use of physical restraint, including prohibited physical restraint, over multiple years, in preference to obtaining expert behavioural assistance.
While traumatising student as per above, the school started suspending the child at 6 years old. Eleven suspensions. No adherence to Student Support Group guidelines. Restraint “teams”. Non adherence to Reportable Conduct Scheme. No adherence to Restraint Policy.
Child disclosed assault by integration aide to third party – slapping of his face. School refused to believe child and aide continues to work.
Worksafe found breaches of OHS Act as school did not provide child sufficient support.
Principal Cameron Nicholls, personally being sued for discrimination 2023.
Practices fully supported by Department of Education which as of 2025 is trying to strike out the matter so it is not publicised.
TYRRELL COLLEGE
Punishment driven school for children with disabilities. Withdrawal of privileges, isolation, seclusion, multiple use of suspensions, threats of expulsion, restricted attendance, informal suspensions (requirements to pick up and take home or keep home), rather than the provision of supports to address disabilities. Don’t follow Department of education policies and procedures in relation to students with disabilities.
As is common in Victorian public schools, after complaints were made, unfounded child protection reports were made.
Negative lifelong impacts on student.
Discrimination complaint settled 2022.
WARRINGA PARK SCHOOL
In 2018, a student died due to negligence by staff including insufficient documentation and lack of appropriate supervision, and the DoE was required to pay significant fine after being taken to court by WorkSafe. Little has changed since then.
In 2024, a parent is taking legal action against the school due to her child being assaulted, not for the first time.
In 2024, a different parent has made a discrimination complaint against the school. The school does not demonstrate an interest in educating children, or teaching them to communicate. It allows children to roam the school instead of attend classes.
VERMONT PRIMARY SCHOOL
Autistic boy has had numerous injuries throughout 2017/2018 at the school that cannot be explained, particularly concerning as the school claims this child has one to one support at all times. Family left after ongoing unsuccessful attempts to obtain supports for their son, and due to concerns about his physical safety. Child Protection notification made after complaint about school. This is a common occurrence for parents of students with disabilities when they make complaints against Victorian schools. Discrimination complaint made 2018.
WENDOUREE PRIMARY SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Restraint used against child with Autism Spectrum Disorder. Practices fully supported by Department of Education.
WESTERN AUTISTIC SCHOOL Restrictive Practices Reported
Restrictive practices
Numerous reports of restraint and seclusion from parents and students. Heavy reliance on seclusion. Aversive techniques endorsed and part of policy (google “aversive stimulus”).
Seclusion incidents not recorded and provided to parents.Discrimination complaint linked with restrictive practices settled by DET.
WONGA PARK PRIMARY SCHOOL – Restrictive Practices, Neglect
School uses physical restraint and denies it, despite numerous witnesses. independent witness, web author confirmed directly with child. Individual Education Plans comprise 2 sentences in meeting minutes. Refusal to allow therapists in school led to child developing Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, vocal tics, fear of other children and Selective Mutism. Child reports that their funded aide was often not in their classroom. When holding Student Support Group meetings, Principal mutes parents and their practitioners and controls when they are allowed to speak.
Discrimination complaint 2022. Principal Julie Crawford.
Practices fully supported by Department of Education.